Article View: sci.anthropology.paleo
Article #98871Re: Bluefish Cave Site
From: icycalmca@yahoo.
Date: Sat, 01 May 2004 22:30
Date: Sat, 01 May 2004 22:30
43 lines
1709 bytes
1709 bytes
paleocity@hotmail.com (Lee Olsen) wrote in message news:<40a73547.0404301814.190b734c@posting.google.com>... > "Val Lentz" <vlentz@shaw.ca> wrote.... > > <snip> > > Daryl Krupa summed up the geology of the Chobot's site: "There is no > reason to believe that the Chobots have found material under glacial > till." > > I'm summing up the artifacts, that were claimed to be found under the > glacial till, as geofacts. Just to be perfectly clear, Lee, I can't see how the material above the artifacts could be accurately described as "glacial till". Buck Lake sits on a thick bed of till, and the best guess is that there was only a single glacial advance into that area (and only a single glacial advance into the whole "ice-free corridor" area, for that matter). I.e., whatever is above the artifacts is not glacial till, and so there is no reason to believe that the Chobots found a pre-glacial campsite. In that case, they need not be geofacts, but rather might quite possibly be ordinary post-glacial artifacts, somewhere between 12,000 and 20 years old. > If you are interested, I can try scanning the complete MT article (as > a PDF) and sending it to you. Then you can see the "alleged artifacts" > for yourself. I'm interested; the local library throws out a Mammoth Trumpets older than a year. How big would the PDF file be? (I'd like some warning if it's in the megabyte range). As an aside, Val, I had a chance meeting with a local physical anthropologist / archeologist, who informed me that the present head of the Alberta Archaeological Survey has done some work on the Chobot site. I'll be contacting him next week, to hear what he thinks of it. Daryl Krupa
Message-ID:
<c70365ef.0405012130.53218553@posting.google.com>
Path:
rocksolid-us.pugleaf.net!archive.newsdeef.eu!mbox2nntp-sci.anthropology.paleo.(164827).mbox.7z!not-for-mail
References:
<40704B40.3020102@earthlink.net> <d24f0b9f.0404100947.54a0af68@posting.google.com> <Dy2ec.6517$K_.207639@bgtnsc05-news.ops.worldnet.att.net> <d24f0b9f.0404102150.6c3469dc@posting.google.com> <N9dec.3382$l75.1363@newsread2.news.atl.earthlink.net> <c70365ef.0404122219.86130be@posting.google.com> <ozzfc.129780$Ig.92682@pd7tw2no> <40a73547.0404170954.768bad49@posting.google.com> <Hyvkc.305139$Pk3.52671@pd7tw1no> <40a73547.0404301814.190b734c@posting.google.com>