Article View: alt.arts.poetry.comments
Article #818161Re: PPB: May / Christina Rossetti
From: "George J. Dance
Date: Tue, 31 May 2022 14:25
Date: Tue, 31 May 2022 14:25
50 lines
1901 bytes
1901 bytes
(piggy-backing, since the original's no longer on my usenet feed. > NancyGene <nancygene.andjayme@gmail.com> wrote in > news:bc117ec3-886d-48d8-8472-b5e47a8ba118n@googlegroups.com: > >> On Saturday, May 21, 2022 at 4:19:37 AM UTC, george...@yahoo.ca wrote: >>> On 2022-05-18 8:25 p.m., Michael Pendragon wrote: >>>> >>>> When you fail to pick up on literary references in the title of a >>>> book, one wonders if you understand the book at all. >>> Hear that, NG? Remember your review of "The Handmaid's Tale," in >>> which you completely failed to pick up on the literary reference in >>> the title? >> Just because we didn't mention it doesn't mean that we didn't >> recognize it. We cannot cover everything in our reviews. The Virgin >> Mary was a handmaid to God, and Rachel, Bilhah, and Jacob fooled >> around in Genesis. >> >> George Dance, why didn't you (or Jordy's Uncle) mention the origin of >> the title? (1) neither of us were writing a "review". (2) As you'd know if you've read the thread, I disagree with Michael: I don't think knowing the reference of a title is necessary to understand a novel or a poem. (It might add 'depth' of understanding, but it isn't crucial for understanding the work at all). >> From now on, all references to titles of songs, books, >> poems, etc., must analyze from whence the title came. > Or you can disagree with Michael, too. Take your pick. > >>> Now you know what that means. >> We always knew what it meant. > Well, now that you understand its implications, you have to decide whether you agree with it or not. Have fun deciding. > Do you have any evidence that can be backed up by a Mensa member? > Otherwise it will be completely discredited as plagiarism, cut and paste > or some other lame fucking excuse by the Columbus Pissbum Collective who > must think it's important enough to spam a newsgroup over it. (TINCPC). >
Message-ID:
<t75mi0$18e$1@dont-email.me>
Path:
rocksolid-us.pugleaf.net!archive.newsdeef.eu!apf1.newsdeef.eu!not-for-mail
References:
<t516r5$2nk$1@dont-email.me> <fc14ad86-037e-4d06-b748-ab3c3fd2d360n@googlegroups.com> <46cb941e-afe6-412d-829f-faa2c5d7fa6an@googlegroups.com> <a060318a-48f0-48b7-8f06-7c23975469d6n@googlegroups.com> <t63m6k$86g$2@dont-email.me> <749ebbd1-84eb-46de-a45a-25110091301cn@googlegroups.com> <t69p8n$5bp$1@dont-email.me> <bc117ec3-886d-48d8-8472-b5e47a8ba118n@googlegroups.com> <XnsAE9E8F4E33F11PantyheadPoorHouse@144.76.35.252>